High-Level Disinfectant vs. Low-Level Disinfectant – Which is Right For My Business?

Choosing the proper disinfectant is critical to maintaining a hygienic environment for your business. However, not all disinfectants are created equal, and understanding the differences between high-level disinfectants (HLDs) and low-level disinfectants (LLDs) can make or break your cleaning and safety protocols. For businesses across Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin—whether managing a hospital, school, daycare, or corporate office—using the wrong disinfectant can lead to healthcare-associated infections (HAIs), regulatory violations, and financial repercussions. This article explores high-level and low-level disinfectants, their strengths and limitations, and how you can make an informed decision tailored to your facility’s unique needs.

What Are Low-Level Disinfectants?

Low-level disinfectants (LLDs) are chemical cleaning solutions designed to eliminate most bacteria, some viruses, and some fungi. They effectively eliminate non-spore-forming vegetative bacteria, including Staphylococcus aureus, E. coli, and Salmonella. The proliferation of these bacteria can cause serious foodborne illnesses and skin infections. Low-level disinfectants are an effective solution to eliminate certain types of fungi, including Candida albicans, Aspergillus spp, and Trichophyton spp. These fungi thrive in moist or high-touch areas such as locker rooms, shared towels, and bed sheets. They are responsible for causing ailments such as ringworm, athlete’s foot and pose a risk to individuals with compromised immune systems. 

Many low-level disinfectant products contain quaternary ammonium compounds (QACs). These chemicals break open the membranes of bacteria and the outer coatings of viruses, causing cell death. These disinfectants often contain ingredients such as diluted bleach or phenolic-based solutions. A wide range of products contain QACs, from toothpaste to shampoos. Common everyday use cases in business settings include Lysol® Multi-Surface Cleaner, Clorex Wipes, and Purell hand sanitizer.

When Are Low-Level Disinfectants Ideal?

Low-level disinfectants are ideal for disinfecting non-critical areas and surfaces that do not come into contact with hazardous materials or biological fluids. Businesses, including offices and financial institutions, can benefit from these disinfectants for routine cleaning of shared surfaces, including light switches, chairs, and conference room tables. Schools and universities can effectively utilize LLDs to reduce germ transmission on desks, cafeteria trays, and playground equipment. Gyms and sports training facilities can eliminate common germs by applying low-level disinfectants on lockers, exercise equipment, and door handles. Retail stores can disinfect shopping carts, checkout counters, and display shelves to safeguard customers and employees against everyday germs. 

Limitations of Low-Level Disinfectants

While cost-effective and easy to use, low-level disinfectants have significant limitations:

  1. Limited Spectrum: LLDs do not eliminate resistant bacteria, bacterial spores, or certain viruses. In healthcare settings like elderly care facilities or VA hospitals, relying on LLDs could put vulnerable populations at risk of infection. For example, surfaces exposed to Clostridium difficile (C. diff), a spore-forming bacterium, cannot be properly disinfected with low-level cleaning solutions.

  2. Unsuitability for Critical Equipment: Low-level disinfectants are inadequate for surgical instruments, endoscopes, or any equipment that comes into contact with mucous membranes. Using LLDs in these cases could result in healthcare-associated infections, lawsuits, and regulatory penalties.

  3. Frequent Reapplication: Many low-level disinfectants require frequent reapplication to remain effective. For example, in a sports training facility, sweat and organic matter can degrade the efficacy of LLDs quickly, requiring constant cleaning.

Low-level disinfectants offer an affordable and practical solution for general cleaning and hygiene maintenance to reduce the spread of common bacteria and viruses. However, if there is an outbreak of norovirus or influenza, these products may not be sufficient to eradicate the more robust viruses. LLDs are ineffective to kill more potent pathogens like tuberculosis bacteria or certain types of hepatitis viruses making them unsuitable for specific businesses. 

What Are High-Level Disinfectants?

High-level disinfectants (HLDs) are chemical cleaning agents specifically formulated to eliminate all microorganisms, including bacteria, viruses, fungi, and resilient pathogens. HLDs are particularly utilized in healthcare environments such as hospitals, surgical centers, and dental clinics. High-risk environments rely on HLDs to disinfect medical instruments, endoscopes, and other reusable devices that come into contact with mucous membranes or enter sterile body areas. 

High-level disinfectants include hydrogen peroxide-based solutions, glutaraldehyde, and peracetic acid, all known for their broad-spectrum antimicrobial properties. Cidex® OPA and Sporicidin® Disinfectant are HDL products commonly used to ensure compliance with infection control standards. “Standard Precautions” are mandated practices designed to prevent transmitting healthcare-associated infections during patient care. These practices include hand hygiene, proper use of personal protective equipment (PPE), safe handling of sharps, respiratory hygiene (cough etiquette), and effective cleaning and disinfection. HLDs’ ability to neutralize a wide range of pathogens makes them indispensable in preventing healthcare-associated infections and protecting patients and staff in settings where the stakes for infection control are exceptionally high.

When Are High-Level Disinfectants Ideal?

HLDs are the gold standard for areas and equipment requiring the highest level of disinfection. For instance, HLDs are essential for disinfecting surgical instruments, endoscopes, and other semi-critical medical devices in hospitals and surgical centers. Another great application is daycare facilities. Children often put toys and other objects into their mouths, making these items a hotspot for pathogens. When used appropriately, high-level disinfectants can ensure toys, changing tables, and other shared surfaces are properly sanitized, preventing outbreaks of highly contagious diseases like rotavirus or hand, foot, and mouth disease.

HLDs also play a crucial role in environments with a high risk of spore contamination, such as elderly care facilities or hospitals where C. diff outbreaks are a concern. In these cases, products like Clorox Healthcare® Hydrogen Peroxide Cleaner Disinfectant Wipes can effectively eliminate pathogens that LLDs cannot.

Limitations of High-Level Disinfectants

Despite their superior disinfection power, HLDs come with their own set of challenges:

  1. Cost: High-level disinfectants are more expensive than low-level options. For example, while an LLD like Lysol may cost a few dollars per gallon, a medical-grade HLD like Cidex® can cost significantly more. Overusing HLDs in non-critical areas can lead to unnecessary expenses for businesses with tight budgets.

  2. Toxicity and Handling Risks: Many HLDs require special training and protective gear to handle them safely. Improper use can pose health risks to cleaning staff, including respiratory irritation, skin burns, and long-term health effects. For instance, glutaraldehyde, a common HLD, can cause severe allergic reactions if not handled properly.

  3. Not Suitable for Routine Cleaning: Using high-level disinfectants on low-risk surfaces, such as office desks or museum displays, is overkill and inefficient. Overuse can also lead to unnecessary chemical exposure, harming people and the environment.

Risk Factors of Improper Disinfectant Use

The improper use of low-level or high-level disinfectants can have negative consequences. Using an LLD in a high-risk environment like a VA hospital could result in infections, lawsuits, and even patient deaths. Conversely, overusing HLDs in a corporate office wastes money, increases chemical exposure, and creates potential health risks for employees and cleaning staff.

Failing to follow manufacturers’ instructions for disinfectant use—such as incorrect dilution, insufficient dwell time, or mixing incompatible chemicals—can render even the best disinfectants ineffective. Improper usage increases the likelihood of pathogen survival and transmission. 

How Bee Line Support Can Help Your Business

Deciding between high-level and low-level disinfectants is no easy task, especially when every facility has its own unique needs. That’s where Bee Line Support comes in. As a certified medical-grade commercial cleaning company, we bring expertise and tailored cleaning solutions to Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin businesses. Whether you’re managing a hospital, daycare, university, sports training facility, or office building, we help you navigate the complexities of disinfection with precision.

We train all our janitorial staff in the latest cleaning technologies and protocols, ensuring we apply the proper disinfectants to the right areas. With Bee Line Support, you don’t have to worry about health risks, regulatory compliance, or wasting money on the wrong products. We take the guesswork out of commercial cleaning, delivering peace of mind and a spotless facility.

Hiring a professional cleaning company like Bee Line Support is an investment that pays for itself. Contact us today to learn more about how we can keep your facility clean, safe, and thriving. Click “Get A Quote”

About The Author

More To Explore:

Share:

More Posts

Send Us A Message